scar evil?

[graff]

do you think scar is evil or is he good?

[ZrAeNiAn]

Scar is a person acting out of hate and love for his brother. Its hard to say good or bad, i think he is more of a 3th party in the conflicts. a key element in the story but you cant label him good or bad.

-Zr-

[vegita625]

Scar is a person acting out of hate and love for his brother. Its hard to say good or bad, i think he is more of a 3th party in the conflicts. a key element in the story but you cant label him good or bad.

-Zr-
Depends, are you going to judge him based on his intentions, the nature of how he acts, or by the conciquences? Intentions, not very good, but not bad either. Nature... just plain not good, he kills people. Consequences... he kills people... mainly I'd say evil, but I've had way too much review of one day of ethics class in one post. Seriously, though, I'd say he's an man with good intentions and a bad way of carrying them out... kinda.

[Full Metal Faust]

now scar is the guy that disasembled that dog/girl thind right

[venin]

he is just comfused guy who is in need of moral lesson

[AngelWingz]

he was sort of bad in the beginning, but towards the end he turned into a good guy to help his people....... I wish he would have had a cooler death tho. :cry:

[Lanze]

he was sort of bad in the beginning, but towards the end he turned into a good guy to help his people....... I wish he would have had a cooler death tho. :cry:

LMAO yea, gettin both this arms blown off, then getting shot, then he just keeled over and died seems kinda ~Painsful~ to me 0o

[graff]

thats the beauty that is FMA. you would think that scar would go out in the blaze of glory with this high and mighty death...but he doesnt.

[Akumakage-Dono]

I'd say he is more neutral. He is only doing what he believes is right.

[Leachu]

Well, depends how you look at it. He kills alchemists in return for the death of his brother.So I would say he isnt good nor evil.He just seeks revenge.

[Leachu]

Well, actually, i take that back, he kinda is nuetral, but in some peoples eyes, he is evil..... so he is more on the evil side 8)

[sakurablossomfighter]

I agree with u!

[Nafnir]

he was sort of bad in the beginning, but towards the end he turned into a good guy to help his people....... I wish he would have had a cooler death tho.
HE wasnt bad in the begining, you only see it that way early on cause you dont know his intentions or why he does it. What hes trying to do is *SPOILER*SPOILER*SPOILER*SPOILER*SPOILER*SPOILER*S POILER just to create the philosopher stone, his intentions never changed, you just got to know what they were the more you watched.

[Yamiko Ryu]

now scar is the guy that disasembled that dog/girl thind right

Yes that is him....

On another note i'd say he is an Anti-hero to most he is bad but to some he is good....Or just sorta there...

[IshvarlanScar]

I think it's all based on how he sees his actions. If he thinks killing State Alchemists is right... Wait, no, it's not right, is it? Ah well, so he's a psycho. He's awesome.

<< unable to dig deeper beneath the surface... because she is an idiot.

[Pryce]

killing random Alchemists and anyone who gets in the way.....yeah sounds pretty evil to me